Integrated Solar Tiles vs. Traditional Solar Panels: What’s Better When Reroofing a House?

Introduction

If you’re planning to reroof your home, it’s the perfect time to consider solar. Instead of adding panels later, you can decide now whether to install traditional solar panels or opt for integrated solar tiles that become part of the roof itself. Both solutions provide clean energy, but they differ in installation, cost, design, and long-term value.

This guide breaks down the pros and cons of each option so you can make the best choice when replacing your roof.

1. Installation During a Reroof

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Installed after the roof is complete.

• Require racks that are bolted into the new roof, potentially creating penetrations that can shorten roof lifespan.

• Adds extra labor and a second project phase after reroofing.

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Installed at the same time as the new roof.

• Replace sections of shingles or concrete tiles, so they serve as both the roofing material and the solar system.

• Eliminates the need for drilling or racks on your brand-new roof.

Best Fit: Integrated solar tiles — ideal when reroofing since you avoid redundant labor.

2. Long-Term Durability

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Mounted above the roof, which can create uplift points in strong winds.

• May outlast or underlast the roof beneath them, creating future removal costs if you need to reroof again.

• 
  

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Built directly into the roofline, flush with the surface.

• Withstand high winds, hail, and heavy rain—making them a strong choice for homeowners in hurricane-prone regions.

• Lifespan often matches or exceeds that of premium roofing materials.

Best Fit: Integrated solar tiles, for aligned roof and solar lifespans.

3. Aesthetic Considerations

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Often bulky and sit above the roof, which may not align with a newly upgraded roof design.

• Can be restricted in neighborhoods with HOA or historic rules.

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Blend seamlessly with the new roof, resembling slate, clay, or concrete tiles.

• Preserve the home’s curb appeal while still generating energy.

Best Fit: Integrated solar tiles, especially for design-conscious homeowners.

4. Cost and Value When Reroofing

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Lower upfront cost than tiles.

• However, if you install panels right after reroofing, you’re essentially paying for two systems: a full roof replacement plus a mounted solar system.

• If the roof needs repair before the panels reach the end of their life, you’ll face removal and reinstallation costs.

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Higher upfront investment, but they replace roofing material.

• Provide dual value: a new roof and a solar system in one project.

• May boost resale value thanks to their durability and clean, integrated appearance.

Best Fit: Integrated solar tiles, if you want roofing + solar combined into one long-term investment.

5. Energy Performance

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Slightly more efficient per square foot.

• Can be tilted or angled for optimal sunlight capture.

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Efficiency is improving but may be slightly lower per tile compared to panels.

• However, since you’re redoing the roof, the overall system can be designed to maximize sun exposure across the roof surface.

Best Fit: Depends — panels may win on smaller roofs, while tiles are strong for larger reroof projects.

6. Environmental Impact

Traditional Solar Panels:

• Add more materials (racks, frames, mounts) on top of the new roof.

• Can lead to extra waste during installation or future roof replacements.

Integrated Solar Tiles:

• Replace roofing materials instead of doubling up.

• Reduce waste while generating renewable energy.

• Qualify for the federal solar tax credit and state incentives just like panels.

Best Fit: Integrated solar tiles, for sustainable construction during reroofing.

Conclusion

When it comes to reroofing a house, integrated solar tiles provide the strongest long-term value. They combine the roof and solar system into one, reduce future maintenance headaches, and preserve aesthetics. Traditional panels may still work for homeowners seeking a lower upfront cost, but they can complicate a brand-new roof with penetrations and potential mismatched lifespans.

If you’re investing in a reroof, it’s worth weighing the dual benefits of integrated solar tiles: protection, clean energy, and a roof built to last.

Related Resources

• Extreme Weather Roofing Guide

• Hurricane Standards for Solar Roofs

• Solar Roof Options in HOA Communities

• The Future of Building-Integrated Photovoltaics (BIPV)